|
Post by kwhite18 on Jan 11, 2013 22:20:59 GMT -5
I really liked the textured surface for the button, as well as the illuminating feature for the clock face- I hadn't thought about needing that for an analog clock but it obviously makes perfect sense! I also like the volume setting. I didn't think about including this in my design, but I know that I hate loud alarm clocks (I generally wake up with an alarm easily) and do one of those "Don't Wake Dad!" kind of sit ups if an alarm is too loud. I also think that having both the battery and AC option is important. Good design!
|
|
|
Post by kwhite18 on Jan 11, 2013 22:25:40 GMT -5
Fiona, I really like how you included the actual alarm time on the clock face. Not only can the person see that the alarm is on, but also verify what time it is set for. The slider button for the alarm setting is great, too. It makes it a lot easier than potentially hitting an off button by mistake. My only criticism is that I think it's a lot of buttons to have all in one place. This is really just personal clumsiness, but I'm prone to smacking around until the alarm shuts off. This clock would be dangerous in my hands! But like I said, that's just personal preference. Good job!
|
|
|
Post by mgarnett on Jan 12, 2013 11:31:33 GMT -5
In creating my alarm clock ( terpconnect.umd.edu/~mleist/t5/), I first thought about what features I thought it necessary to have. It needed to display the time, have a way to set the time, have a way to turn on the alarm, have a way to set an alarm, have a way to differentiate between AM and PM, and have a power source. There are a number of features I like in this alarm clock - the shape, the analog face, the battery option (all things which also match my design, I admit). The options for alarm sound are a nice 'extra', although they might not be particularly intuitive on first use. Two things I found a bit confusing. The first is the alarm-setting component. Are those digital numbers shown there? Or a roller display of some sort? It does allow a bit more precision than the usual single alarm hand in setting (where you sort of guess that it's pointing at quarter past, more or less, or maybe it'll be 20 or 10 past), but will it add confusion for setting, since it's not as obviously 'mapped' to the main clock face? My second question is the am/pm buttons, and their necessity. As with most analog alarm clocks, this one has a single on/off switch: either the alarm is on, or it's not, unlike digital alarms where the thing is on around the clock, and you only turn it off for the day. This would have the advantage of letting you set the alarm up to 23ish hours in advance, as opposed to 12. But as a carry-over, what about the am/pm on the clock face? Can you set those separately, or is it like a watch where you have to go through the full twenty-four hours to get it set up right? I can see where it might be a nice added feature, but at the cost of some visual affordance & simplicity.
|
|
|
Post by areigle on Jan 12, 2013 11:56:00 GMT -5
Here is a link to my alarm clock!: terpconnect.umd.edu/~areigle/t5/index.htmlI went a very simple route when I designed mine. I thought about what I want in an alarm clock and personally I just like the clock to have that one purpose as I think too many other options frustrate me. I kept the idea in mind that instructions on how to use it should be minimal and that the functions of the buttons or switches should pretty obvious. The one button that you would have to use a couple of times before you understand it’s purpose would be the “Alarm Set” button. When you press it the display changes from the current time to the alarm time and to actually set the alarm, using the “hours +” and “mins +” buttons, you have to hold the button. This was perhaps the only button I had that I think would need further instruction. However, it has become a common function on many digital clocks currently, so the learning curve might not be so bad. The “hours +” and “mins +” buttons are also something that might be frustrating to users but has also been a standard in digital alarms clocks. I had them only add time as I think adding another function to allow movement in the other direction can add another step that might be confusing and add clutter. To change from AM to PM you have to add hours until AM or PM is indicated on the digital display. The switch on the top indicates whether the alarm is on or off as simply as possible, in my opinion as well as the snooze option. Overall, I took in consideration the specific purpose of an alarm clock and tried to make a clock that required as little instruction as possible. I also tried to think of the difficulty it takes to make a clock with too many other buttons or options and what users are familiar with according to digital alarm clocks.
|
|
|
Post by areigle on Jan 12, 2013 12:09:09 GMT -5
I really like the simplicity of your clock. When I look at it I can definitely understand the functions of all of the buttons. I personally really like the use of the rocking buttons - I wish I would have thought of them!They're great at combining 2 buttons into one and associating their functions (-/+) visually. If you had two buttons (like me...) there is a chance they could be mistaken for two different functions. The large numbers are great, not only with people with bad vision, but just because when anyone wakes-up they are disoriented and need something very simple and clear, especially if, as it is in most cases, used to wake-up when it's still dark out.
|
|
|
Post by areigle on Jan 12, 2013 12:21:09 GMT -5
You have two comprehensive drawings for your clock! I actually really like the idea of using dials for setting your times. That was the function I had issues thinking through, but I think you have a great idea for an analog clock. Having an analog clock allows for you to disregard having to work in an AM/PM indicator or switch, which streamlines things a little. Some users might like to set alarms for times way in advance, but I think this is a bit more straightforward for novice users which frees up some space for you to add the volume button. Putting the functions related to the alarm on one side and those related to the clock on the other is also a good way to avoid confusing the user.
|
|
|
Post by stuszynski on Jan 12, 2013 12:35:33 GMT -5
I love the enormous Snooze button on the front. Very easy to see and find, no risk of hitting the wrong thing. I completely forgot about setting the time on my clock, so now I feel sheepish! I like that the alarm set and time set are on different sides of the clock, so it's easier to know which one you're setting.
|
|
|
Post by stuszynski on Jan 12, 2013 12:38:35 GMT -5
I think it was a good design choice to make the alarm on/off a switch rather than a button, so the user can tell by feel (in the dark in the early morning, as we do) which thing they want to hit, either alarm off or the snooze button The only thing that could be a drawback would be that the front of the clock doesn't indicate whether the alarm is on or off. You'd have to look at the switch on top to tell and that might be difficult to see. Otherwise I think the design is pretty solid for anyone who has encountered an alarm clock before, far less complicated than many of them.
|
|
|
Post by taneshaalex on Jan 12, 2013 15:34:43 GMT -5
Below please find the link to my alarm clock! terpconnect.umd.edu/~talexan1 in the t5 folder. I chose this design because I have always been fascinated with the old simple alarm clocks. The simplicity I tried to create was based on how complicated alarms are now days. The digital light is abrasive and hard to look at, not to mention the annoying beeping sound makes waking up a startling event. Though the old alarm clocks clang and are just as abrasive, there is no digital light and it is actually difficult to turn off forcing the sleepier to exert some thought into turning it off. With my design, I chose to be as simple. I chose shapes that I believe would resemble the old clocks I have seen before in the past. I put numbers on the face, just to let everyone know its a clock, but did not puts hands as I felt it would have made the design look cluttered. I also made the face of the clock white so that the numbers would show better and breakup the blue monotony. I made the design in Microsoft PowerPoint instead of uploading a photo, simply because I wanted to make my own rendition of what an alarm clock resembles. I used ovals, straight lines and a curved shape to make the clock. These shapes were easy to manipulate and offered less hassle in getting the correct shape size.
|
|
|
Post by taneshaalex on Jan 12, 2013 16:42:17 GMT -5
The alarm clock by terpconnect.umd.edu/~fjardine/t5/ is very descriptive! I also like that it is handwritten! The large number display helps me see exactly what time it is. I also like how regardless whether the display is illuminated you can see the display options. I also like the large snooze button which makes it easy to hit when your half asleep. I am wondering how big this alarm clock would be, would it even fit on my nightstand? I also wonder what color the display would be? Red? Blue?
|
|
|
Post by taneshaalex on Jan 12, 2013 16:45:44 GMT -5
The alarm design by terpconnect.umd.edu/~mleist/t5/, I think is wonderful! I like the large snooze button at the top, it makes it easy to hit and go back to sleep! I also like the wind up button on the side, this reminds me of setting a watch. I am curious about some of the buttons on the back. The sounds switch in particular, I wonder what type of sounds will the clock produce? Beeps? Birds? I think this design is simple, just like an alarm clock should be!
|
|
|
Post by ewrenn on Jan 12, 2013 18:36:44 GMT -5
I prefer small, transportable alarm clocks. Currently I use my telephone's alarm, but transportable clocks can be useful on trips, specifically when you cannot charge your phone or it doesn't work (e.g. abroad when a phone doesn't have service and essentially becomes a complex alarm clock). The clock displayed could be either battery or socket powered, but to highlight the clock's transportability battery-powered would be better. terpconnect.umd.edu/~ewrenn/t5/These are the main functions that I want a clock to have: - Digital Time The time display is large and digital. A user should be able to read the time easily from across the room. A user sets the time on the right side of the clock. The user can see the front display while pressing the minute, hour, and AM/PM buttons on the right to adjust the time. The user adjusts the alarm time by moving the switch to the "Set Alarm" position. When the switch is in the "Set Alarm" position the buttons on the right adjust the alarm's minute, hour, and AM-PM settings. The date can be set/adjusted using the right panel of the clock by setting the switch to the "Set Date" position. In the "Set Date" Position the buttons control the date's day, month, and year, respectively. Pushing the switch all the way down to the "Setting Locked" position disables the Set Clock buttons. -AM/PM Display The AM/PM display is clearly illuminated beside the time display. -Date The date is displayed with the day first, month next, and year last. The superscript D,M, and Y are added so that the user clearly knows 3/1/2013 is March 1st rather than January 3rd. -Day A user does not need to set the day. Once the date is selected the clock will recognize the day because the information is preloaded in the clock's computer. -Alarm The user knows when the alarm is set because of the bell display on the front of the clock. The bell disappears when the alarm is turned off. The user can set the alarm on the left side of the clock. The options are clearly labeled: the alarm is on when the switch is up and it is off when the switch is down. -Snooze The clock has a large snooze button on the top of the clock. There are no other buttons on the top of the clock so that a user doesn't mistakenly hit the snooze button while tying to hit another.
|
|
|
Post by ewrenn on Jan 12, 2013 18:51:02 GMT -5
My alarm clock is stunningly rendered at terpconnect.umd.edu/~fjardine/t5/First, I thought back to some of the alarm clocks I have had to use in hotels and how hard they were to use. I thought about the essentials of an alarm clock and came up with the following list: - large, lit-up display of current time - ability to set both the time and alarm without consulting the instruction book - a big snooze button - obvious and easy to use button to turn the alarm on and off and something on the screen to display whether the alarm is on or off My design could work either digitally, for example on a computer, smartphone, or tablet, or physically as an alarm clock if you were "fold" the design just above the display (i.e. the buttons would be on the top of the alarm clock and the display on the front). The numbers are large and illuminated. To the side of the numbers are areas that can be lit-up or darkened depending on their status. These include AM/PM for the current time, whether the alarm is off or on, and what time the alarm is set for if it is turned on. The snooze button is large and easy to find in a sleepy haze. The alarm on/off slider clearly shows the status of the alarm and is easy to find when you want to turn the alarm off after hitting the snooze button numerous times. The buttons to change current time and alarm time should probably be a little smaller (to make the snooze button larger in relation to them), but my drawing skills are not the best in the world... There are simple directions on the buttons themselves ("Press + Hold to change time/alarm") with simple "hour +" and "minute +" buttons next to them. I think this alarm clock would be obvious to use (buttons are pressed, sliders are slid), and very quick to complete tasks required (setting alarm time and whether it is on or off). This drawing and clock concept is great. I particularly like the feature where the user can see not only that the alarm is set, but for what time it is set. That adds clarity so that someone easily can see when s/he set the alarm time rather than having to push a handful of buttons to find the information. Overall the clock has a simple straightforward design that doesn't require detailed instructions to understand how to work the clock.
|
|
|
Post by ewrenn on Jan 12, 2013 19:16:38 GMT -5
terpconnect.umd.edu/~kwhite18/t5-2/In designing the alarm clock I thought it would be most useful to keep its functions basic and easy to distinguish. - Time Display: The time display should be large enough for weary eyes to see, regardless of whether or not it's across the room or on the bedside table. I also though that the display color was important as well. Personally, I am very light sensitive and prefer it to be as dark as possible. The red color is visibile but not intrusive. - Time AM/PM: This goes along with the time display, but is worth noting that an AM/PM display to accompany the time is essential especially when the clock is used with as an alarm. - Alarm Status: A simple display that shows whether the alarm is on or off will help users to avoid mishaps. - Snooze Button: Every alarm clock needs a snooze button. This button is directly below the display and is the only botton on the front face. I am notorious for thinking that I'm hitting the snooze when I'm actually turning the alarm off. Designing the clock with only one button on the face will eliminate button confusion. To make sure that the user doesn't confuse normal clock and alarm functions, the alarm functions are on the left side and the clock functions are on the right. -Setting the Alarm: By holding the "Set Alarm" button and pressing the "Hours" and "Minutes" buttons, the alarm can be set. The AM/PM display will change with the numbers to represent morning or evening times. -Alarm On/Off: A sliding switch will turn the alarm on or off, triggering the front display to show its status. -Setting the Time: By holding the "Set Time" button and pressing the "Hours" and "Minutes" buttons, the time on the clock can be set. The AM/PM display will change with the numbers to represent morning or evening times. -The rear of the clock houses the AC Power Plug-in and back-up battery box in case of electricity loss. This example is well executed. The alarm clock has basic features, but each feature is explained well and justified. There are two features in particular that seriously consider usability. First, the snooze and alarm-off controls are in two separate parts of the clock. The designer considered how people use the clock, recognizing unfortunate instances when a sleeper turns off the alarm when s/he really just wants another 5 minutes of sleep. As the author noted, separating the two buttons eliminates button confusion. On a similar note, separating the alarm set and time set features limits confusion setting one or the other. Though, the settings are similar so there is consistency on both sides of the clock. The only recommendation I would add is to make a wider base or find another way to stabilize the clock. I see this clock being knocked over easily on snooze mornings.
|
|
|
Post by jian12 on Jan 12, 2013 20:43:17 GMT -5
Please see my alarm design on terpconnect.umd.edu/~jian12/t5/I forgot to fix the shape-the sharp corners should actually be like curves. Two features of my design are music change function and light. I sometimes get too used to the alarm sound that I could possibly ignore it... Different music or even FM radio would be nice. As for light, I believe it very useful because you sometimes need it to read the clock, easy but now too bright. The light blue light can also make the alarm cube pretty and romantic. By the way, I make the top of the alarm a big button: SNOOZE if clicking once, light if clicking twice. I'm wondering what will happen if snooze button is super tiny. Is this design going to motivate you to get up right away? ;D
|
|